New York Yankees Grade 5 Sports Trading Cards & Accessories

Shop by Category

Shop by Manufacturer

4,230 Results

1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle #253 New York Yankees PSA 5 BEAUTIFUL STUNNING RC
~~ AMT MEMORABILIA ~~ NOW ACCEPTING CONSIGNMENTS!
New (Other) · Bowman
$19,800.00
$200.00 shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
39 bids
6d 3h
1950 Bowman Ed Lopat New York Yankees Card PSA 5
New (Other) · Bowman
$25.00
$5.55 shipping
1 bid
52m 9s
1953 Topps Ted Gray PSA 5 EX #52 Detroit Tigers
New (Other) · Topps
$11.50
$4.99 shipping
4 bids
2h 11m
New Listing1948 Leaf Babe Ruth- NY Yankees- #3 PSA 5 - Yankees - New PSA Label
New (Other) · Leaf
$9,500.00
or Best Offer
$15.00 shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
1933 GOUDEY BABE RUTH #181 PSA 5 BOLD COLOR EXCELLENT PRINT &CLARITY YANKEES HOF
New (Other) · Goudey
$7,500.00
Free shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
33 bids
6d 3h
1954 Topps #17 Phil Rizzuto ** PSA EX 5 * New York Yankees vintage baseball card
New (Other)
$88.00
Free shipping
1950 Bowman Yogi Berra SGC 5
New (Other) · Bowman
$370.00
$4.99 shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
0 bids
4d 11h
1969 Topps Reggie Jackson Rookie Card RC #260 PSA 5 EX Athletics - Yankees
New (Other) · Topps
$309.95
$4.49 shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
New Listing1967 TOPPS VENEZUELA #145 JOE DIMAGGIO - SGC 1 - NEW YORK YANKEES - VENEZUELAN
New (Other) · Topps
(1)
$549.99
$7.50 shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
0 bids
2d
New Listing1992 Delphi Babe Ruth - The Called Shot SGC 5
New (Other)
$40.00
or Best Offer
$4.95 shipping
New ListingSGC 5 MICKEY MANTLE 1969 TOPPS #500 *BEAUTIFUL WITH GREAT EYE APPEAL* NY YANKEES
New (Other) · Topps
$142.50
$5.00 shipping
16 bids
6d 2h
1930 Cracker Jack Pins Lou Gehrig New York Yankees HOF PSA 5 EX " RARE "
PROBSTEIN is actively accepting consignments !!
New (Other) · Cracker Jack
$165.50
$18.00 shipping
18 bids
5d 3h
1957 Topps Baseball MICKEY MANTLE Vintage Card #95 SGC 5 EX EXTREMELY RARE!! HOF
New (Other) · Topps
$54.00
$6.00 shipping
9 bids
8d 23h
$Aaron Judge 2022 Topps Stadium Club Chrome Beam Team Red Refractor SGC 9 Mint /5$
Aaron Judge 2022 Topps Stadium Club Chrome Beam Team Red Refractor SGC 9 Mint /5
New (Other) · Topps
$200.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad
1926 W512 #6 Babe Ruth SGC 5. Pop 2
New (Other)
$6,900.00
$10.00 shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
SponsoredSponsored Ad
New ListingWILLIE MCCOVEY 1962 TOPPS BASEBALL CARD #544 PSA 5 EXCELLENT SF GIANTS HOF
New (Other) · Topps
$115.00
$4.95 shipping
New Listing1960 Topps #563 MICKEY MANTLE AS New York YANKEES -- PSA 5 EX -- JUST GRADED --
New (Other) · Topps
$350.00
$7.95 shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
1959 TOPPS #180 YOGI BERRA NEW YORK YANKEES BASEBALL CARD SGC 5 EX
New (Other) · Topps
(2)
$36.00
$4.43 shipping
11 bids
21h 19m
1990 Topps Heads Up #19 - LOW POP Don Mattingly New York Yankees PSA 5
New (Other) · Topps
$2.75
$5.00 shipping
3 bids
1d 22h
Rickey Henderson / Pete Rose 1984 Topps Rub Downs Rare PSA 5 EX HOF Low Pop
New (Other) · Topps
$12.00
$4.00 shipping
1962 Topps World Series "The Winners Celebrate" #237 PSA 5
New (Other) · Topps
$1.99
$5.99 shipping
0 bids
5d 5h
1971 Topps #5 THURMAN MUNSON PSA 5 EX New York Yankees
New (Other) · Topps
$110.00
$5.00 shipping
1959 Topps #202 Roger Maris White Back, Athletics, PSA-EX 5
New (Other) · Topps
$9.99
$5.90 shipping
1 bid
5d 22h
1952 Bowman Joe Collins #181 SGC 5 EX New York Yankees
New (Other) · Bowman
$9.99
$5.99 shipping
0 bids
1d 2h
New Listing1967 Topps #45 Roger Maris PSA 5 EX
New (Other) · Topps
$59.99
or Best Offer
$3.86 shipping
2023 MLB Topps Now #PCA-7 Gerrit Cole #’d /5 GEM MT PSA 10 Yankees Baseball
New (Other) · Topps
$20.05
Free shipping
10 bids
22h 27m
1966 Topps RUB OFFS Whitey Ford Vintage Tattoo Card New York Yankees PSA 5
New (Other) · Topps
$1.25
$5.00 shipping
2 bids
2d 1h
1952 Topps - Correct Bio-Black Back #48 Joe Page PSA 5 EX
New (Other) · Topps
$36.00
$4.38 shipping
2 bids
5d 23h
1961 Topps Brooks Robinson #10 Baltimore Orioles Graded EX 5
New (Other) · Topps
$50.00
or Best Offer
$5.60 shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad
HARMON KILLEBREW 1968 TOPPS BASEBALL CARD #220 MINESOTA TWINS PSA 5
New (Other) · Topps
$34.00
or Best Offer
$4.47 shipping
1962 Topps Baseball Mickey Mantle #200 PSA 5
New (Other) · Topps
(4)
$250.00
Free shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
1 bid
6d 23h
1956 Topps Whitey Ford #240, Graded SGC 5, Excellent. Beautiful art, crisp. HOF.
New (Other) · Topps
(1)
$105.00
or Best Offer
$6.95 shipping
1956 Topps Mickey Mantle #135 PSA 5 EX Beautiful Color and Sharp Corners!!
New (Other) · Topps
$2,700.00
$4.38 shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
22 bids
1d 3h
1957 Topps #2 Yogi Berra (CENTERED) PSA 5 New York Yankees
New (Other) · Topps
$56.00
$3.96 shipping
4 bids
2d
1967 Topps #5 Whitey Ford PSA 5 EX HOF Yankees Nicely Centered~(SS)
New (Other) · Topps
$40.00
$4.75 shipping
1966 Topps RUB OFFS Whitey Ford Vintage Tattoo Card New York Yankees PSA 5
New (Other) · Topps
$6.16
$5.00 shipping
2 bids
2d
1970 Topps #140 Reggie Jackson HOF Oakland A's - Yankees - SGC 5 - NEW SLAB !
New (Other) · Topps
(3)
$59.99
or Best Offer
$6.00 shipping
1964 TOPPS A.L. BOMBERS MARIS/CASH/MANTLE/KALINE ~ HOF #331 BVG 5 EX
New (Other) · Topps
(4)
$99.00
$5.50 shipping
1962 Topps #141 Babe Ruth Special - Twilight Years HOF Graded BGS 5 . 5 EX
New (Other) · Topps
$64.99
or Best Offer
$5.35 shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad
1963 Topps Roger Maris #120 PSA 5
New (Other)
$68.99
$4.95 shipping
YOGI BERRA 1960 Topps #480 SGC 5 New York Yankees HOF - EX
New (Other) · Topps
(1)
$129.99
or Best Offer
$4.99 shipping
1970 TOPPS #189 THURMAN MUNSON YANKEES SGC 5 EX
New (Other) · Topps
$62.95
$5.55 shipping
#208 ELSTON HOWARD, Yankees - 1956 Topps: PSA EX 5, 83794597
New (Other) · Topps
(3)
$52.00
$4.30 shipping
Juan Soto Finest Moments Auto /5 Psa 9
New (Other) · Topps
$500.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
1950 Bowman #215 Ed Lopat New York Yankees Graded PSA 5 EX (Nice Card!)
New (Other) · Bowman
$30.00
or Best Offer
$5.00 shipping
1962 BABE RUTH Special - Topps #140 - GEHRIG & RUTH - SGC 5
New (Other) · Topps
$89.00
$4.50 shipping
1957 Topps Tony Kubek #312 PSA 5 New York Yankees
New (Other) · Topps
$1.99
$5.99 shipping
1 bid
5d 20h
PSA 5 EX 1952 TOPPS MICKEY MANTLE RC HOLY GRAIL ROOKIE CARD AUTHENTIC NY YANKEES
New (Other) · Topps
$300,000.00
or Best Offer
$200.00 shipping
251 watching
Authenticity Guarantee
1934 Goudey #95 Myril Hoag PSA 5
New (Other) · Goudey
$34.00
Free shipping
3 bids
6d 2h
1956 Topps #332 Don Larsen PSA 5 EX New York Yankees
New (Other)
$63.00
Free shipping
New Listing1958 Topps Baseball MICKEY MANTLE All-Star #487 PSA 5 EX New York Yankees HOF
New (Other) · Topps
$3.25
$6.00 shipping
3 bids
9d
1948 Topps Magic Photo #17J William Bendix (Babe Ruth) PSA 5 **Pop. 4, 0 Higher*
New (Other) · Topps
$9.95
$5.95 shipping
1 bid
3d
New Listing2020 Diamond Icons Ichiro Dual Team Relic Auto Red #'ed /5 PSA 5 Mariners Yankee
New (Other)
$50.00
$7.47 shipping
0 bids
6d 23h
1955 BOWMAN MICKEY MANTLE #202 SGC 5 CENTERED NEW LABEL YANKEES HOF GREAT INVEST
New (Other) · Bowman
(1)
$531.00
Free shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
14 bids
6d 3h
1963 Topps - #120 Roger Maris
New (Other) · Topps
(6)
$79.00
or Best Offer
$5.25 shipping
1961 Topps #389 Ralph Terry Yankees 5 - EX
Pre-Owned · Topps
(2)
$5.99
$1.12 shipping
0 bids
1h 44m
1960 Topps Mickey Mantle #350 PSA 5 ++ High End
New (Other) · Topps
(1)
$995.00
Free shipping
1959 Topps #461 Mickey Mantle Hits 42nd Homer For Crown
New (Other) · Topps
(7)
$16.50
$10.00 shipping
3 bids
2d 22h
1961 Topps ROGER MARIS #2 New York Yankees Baseball Card SGC 5 EX.
New (Other) · Topps
$199.00
or Best Offer
$5.35 shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad
PSA/DNA EX 5 Auto 10 1981 Donruss Yogi Berra #351 NEW YORK YANKEES
New (Other) · Donruss
$200.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad

New York Yankees Grade 5 Sports Trading Cards & Accessories

Shop by Category

Shop by Manufacturer

4,230 Results

1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle #253 New York Yankees PSA 5 BEAUTIFUL STUNNING RC

1950 Bowman Ed Lopat New York Yankees Card PSA 5

1953 Topps Ted Gray PSA 5 EX #52 Detroit Tigers

New Listing1948 Leaf Babe Ruth- NY Yankees- #3 PSA 5 - Yankees - New PSA Label

1933 GOUDEY BABE RUTH #181 PSA 5 BOLD COLOR EXCELLENT PRINT &CLARITY YANKEES HOF

1954 Topps #17 Phil Rizzuto ** PSA EX 5 * New York Yankees vintage baseball card

1950 Bowman Yogi Berra SGC 5

1969 Topps Reggie Jackson Rookie Card RC #260 PSA 5 EX Athletics - Yankees

New Listing1967 TOPPS VENEZUELA #145 JOE DIMAGGIO - SGC 1 - NEW YORK YANKEES - VENEZUELAN

New Listing1992 Delphi Babe Ruth - The Called Shot SGC 5

New ListingSGC 5 MICKEY MANTLE 1969 TOPPS #500 *BEAUTIFUL WITH GREAT EYE APPEAL* NY YANKEES

1930 Cracker Jack Pins Lou Gehrig New York Yankees HOF PSA 5 EX " RARE "

1957 Topps Baseball MICKEY MANTLE Vintage Card #95 SGC 5 EX EXTREMELY RARE!! HOF

Aaron Judge 2022 Topps Stadium Club Chrome Beam Team Red Refractor SGC 9 Mint /5

1926 W512 #6 Babe Ruth SGC 5. Pop 2

New ListingWILLIE MCCOVEY 1962 TOPPS BASEBALL CARD #544 PSA 5 EXCELLENT SF GIANTS HOF

New Listing1960 Topps #563 MICKEY MANTLE AS New York YANKEES -- PSA 5 EX -- JUST GRADED --

1959 TOPPS #180 YOGI BERRA NEW YORK YANKEES BASEBALL CARD SGC 5 EX

1990 Topps Heads Up #19 - LOW POP Don Mattingly New York Yankees PSA 5

Rickey Henderson / Pete Rose 1984 Topps Rub Downs Rare PSA 5 EX HOF Low Pop

1962 Topps World Series "The Winners Celebrate" #237 PSA 5

1971 Topps #5 THURMAN MUNSON PSA 5 EX New York Yankees

1959 Topps #202 Roger Maris White Back, Athletics, PSA-EX 5

1952 Bowman Joe Collins #181 SGC 5 EX New York Yankees

New Listing1967 Topps #45 Roger Maris PSA 5 EX

2023 MLB Topps Now #PCA-7 Gerrit Cole #’d /5 GEM MT PSA 10 Yankees Baseball

1966 Topps RUB OFFS Whitey Ford Vintage Tattoo Card New York Yankees PSA 5

1952 Topps - Correct Bio-Black Back #48 Joe Page PSA 5 EX

1961 Topps Brooks Robinson #10 Baltimore Orioles Graded EX 5

HARMON KILLEBREW 1968 TOPPS BASEBALL CARD #220 MINESOTA TWINS PSA 5

1962 Topps Baseball Mickey Mantle #200 PSA 5

1956 Topps Whitey Ford #240, Graded SGC 5, Excellent. Beautiful art, crisp. HOF.

1956 Topps Mickey Mantle #135 PSA 5 EX Beautiful Color and Sharp Corners!!

1957 Topps #2 Yogi Berra (CENTERED) PSA 5 New York Yankees

1967 Topps #5 Whitey Ford PSA 5 EX HOF Yankees Nicely Centered~(SS)

1966 Topps RUB OFFS Whitey Ford Vintage Tattoo Card New York Yankees PSA 5

1970 Topps #140 Reggie Jackson HOF Oakland A's - Yankees - SGC 5 - NEW SLAB !

1964 TOPPS A.L. BOMBERS MARIS/CASH/MANTLE/KALINE ~ HOF #331 BVG 5 EX

1962 Topps #141 Babe Ruth Special - Twilight Years HOF Graded BGS 5 . 5 EX

1963 Topps Roger Maris #120 PSA 5

YOGI BERRA 1960 Topps #480 SGC 5 New York Yankees HOF - EX

1970 TOPPS #189 THURMAN MUNSON YANKEES SGC 5 EX

#208 ELSTON HOWARD, Yankees - 1956 Topps: PSA EX 5, 83794597

Juan Soto Finest Moments Auto /5 Psa 9

1950 Bowman #215 Ed Lopat New York Yankees Graded PSA 5 EX (Nice Card!)

1962 BABE RUTH Special - Topps #140 - GEHRIG & RUTH - SGC 5

1957 Topps Tony Kubek #312 PSA 5 New York Yankees

PSA 5 EX 1952 TOPPS MICKEY MANTLE RC HOLY GRAIL ROOKIE CARD AUTHENTIC NY YANKEES

1934 Goudey #95 Myril Hoag PSA 5

1956 Topps #332 Don Larsen PSA 5 EX New York Yankees

New Listing1958 Topps Baseball MICKEY MANTLE All-Star #487 PSA 5 EX New York Yankees HOF

1948 Topps Magic Photo #17J William Bendix (Babe Ruth) PSA 5 **Pop. 4, 0 Higher*

New Listing2020 Diamond Icons Ichiro Dual Team Relic Auto Red #'ed /5 PSA 5 Mariners Yankee

1955 BOWMAN MICKEY MANTLE #202 SGC 5 CENTERED NEW LABEL YANKEES HOF GREAT INVEST

1963 Topps - #120 Roger Maris

1961 Topps #389 Ralph Terry Yankees 5 - EX

1960 Topps Mickey Mantle #350 PSA 5 ++ High End

1959 Topps #461 Mickey Mantle Hits 42nd Homer For Crown

1961 Topps ROGER MARIS #2 New York Yankees Baseball Card SGC 5 EX.

PSA/DNA EX 5 Auto 10 1981 Donruss Yogi Berra #351 NEW YORK YANKEES

New ListingSGC 5 MICKEY MANTLE 1969 TOPPS #500 BEAUTIFUL WITH GREAT EYE APPEAL NY YANKEES